AI book club questions: choose your book
Each book stands alone. Choose one set of questions for your group; there is no required reading order. These are original companion prompts, not excerpts from the books.
When Great Becomes Average: The Human Consequences of AI
About the book · Start here for work, creativity, families and power.
- Imagine that a skill you spent ten years developing becomes widely available through AI. What has become less scarce? What about your work or your life remains valuable?
- An employer can produce the same result in half the time. Name three ways to use that gain. Who gets to choose, and whose experience would each choice overlook?
- Which difficult task would you still want a child to learn before relying on an assistant? What would count as evidence that the child can do it independently?
- What should a powerful leader make possible for people who disagree with them? Choose one concrete safeguard and explain what failure it could detect.
A useful disagreement: One person argues for faster adoption; another argues for preserving a human practice. Together, name the evidence that could change each position.
AI: An Extension of You
About the book · Start here for memory, creative work and personal judgment.
- Which part of a current project would you delegate to AI, and which decision would you keep? Explain the boundary without using “because humans are better” as the whole answer.
- What should an assistant remember about a project? What should it forget, and how would you notice if it used an outdated decision?
- Two assistants agree on an answer. What additional evidence would you need before acting on it?
- Describe a case where an imperfect suggestion would help you think more than a polished answer. How would you ask for that kind of help?
Try it without private information: Write a short fictional project handoff, change one requirement, and decide how you would check whether an assistant noticed the change. The memory and context guide offers a starting method.
Almost Completely Written By AI
About the book · Start here for evolution, screens and attention.
- Choose a digital signal that reliably attracts you. When does following it help, and when does the same response lead somewhere less useful?
- What does the sea turtle comparison help explain about attention? Which important features of human choice does it leave out?
- How would you distinguish a learned habit, a design change and biological evolution? Why does that distinction matter for what we can change now?
- If you did not know who wrote a paragraph, how would you judge whether it deserved your trust? Would learning that AI drafted it change your test?
Use the research guide to separate an appealing analogy from a claim supported by evidence. · Purpose and cooperation
AI: The Struggle for Perfection: A Bridge to Peace or Chaos
About the book and editions · Start here for purpose, cooperation, and public choices.
- Choose an everyday target: faster replies, more views, or a larger audience. Imagine achieving it perfectly. What could still become worse, and for whom?
- Two groups both want the same shared benefit but disagree about who should act first. What would make a small first step credible? How would you check whether each group kept its promise?
- Now add a third group with different costs and priorities. Which part of the original agreement stops working? Whose voice was missing?
- Take a public claim without naming a person or party. What would you need to distinguish a persuasive message from a well-supported one? What evidence could change your own view?
- Turn one concern into a specific request to someone with the power to change it. What would they do, how could others observe the result, and what would justify revising the request?
A small test: Try the goal-and-consequence exercise. Let one reader defend the proposed goal and another look for a case it misses. Improve the goal together without requiring agreement on every value.
A 30-minute conversation about attention
This original format remains available for the first book. For any of the other books, use its questions above in the same five stages: experience, consequences, a claim to challenge, responsibility, and a small test.
0–5 minutes · Start with a useful signal
Each person names one time a phone helped them: a message, a map, a lesson, a creative tool. Then name a time an attractive signal consumed attention without delivering much. Keep the examples specific; nobody needs to disclose a private experience.
5–12 minutes · Separate cue from consequence
Choose one example. Put three headings on a sheet of paper: what attracted us, what happened, and what we still do not know. Which outcome could be measured? Would more clicks necessarily mean a better result?
12–20 minutes · Challenge an analogy
Compare a hatchling drawn toward a shore lamp with a person following a notification. What makes the comparison useful? Where does it fail? Humans interpret, negotiate, remember, and choose in ways this turtle game cannot represent. Find one claim in the research guide and ask whether it actually tests the human behavior under discussion.
20–27 minutes · Examine AI authorship
Would the same paragraph deserve different scrutiny if written by a human or generated by AI? What matters more: who drafted it, whether its sources support it, whether its uncertainty is clear, or how someone takes responsibility for corrections? Read the book’s authorship disclosure before deciding.
27–30 minutes · Leave with a small test
Choose one reversible change for a specific purpose: a quieter evening, a more focused lesson, or a source check on an AI answer. Say what result would support the change and what would make you reconsider. Agreement is optional; an inspectable question is enough.
Invite disagreement without making anyone defend an identity or diagnosis. Separate personal experience from population claims. Let people pass. These prompts support conversation; they are not therapy, a school policy, or a measure of someone’s well-being.
